Nature or nurture?

What happens when identical twins, born to a teenage mother who’s unable to cope and abandons them, are separately adopted after their less-than-ideal start in life and brought up in decidedly disparate family circumstances?

Yes, I know, it would be unlikely to happen nowadays, when every effort is made to keep adopted siblings together. But it did happen like that in days gone by for various reasons, often, probably, because it was difficult to find would-be adopter parents willing to take on two babies or children together.

So what might happen?

Capture twins for blog

Would the two little individuals – who, but for a very rare chance happening in the first stages of the fertilised egg’s cell division and multiplication, when they separated to become two distinct foetuses – really be, and remain, perfect genetic carbon copies of each other? Or would they, under the influence of differing family environments and social conditions, diverge?

There have been many well-documented cases of separately raised identical twins displaying quite remarkable similarities of character, outlook, aptitude and so on – even life choices. But it isn’t clear-cut. The nature (genetic inheritance) versus nurture (influences of upbringing) debate continues to rumble on.

BBC popular science presenters Michael Moseley and Alice Roberts recently rehearsed the debate yet again although, admittedly, with reference to gender rather than identical twins. It’s the same argument though. Are the things that fundamentally make us tick innate, or acquired and learned?

In my new novel The One of Us, published now, I set up this situation and pose that question.

The One Of Us cover latest_001

My answer to myself is that it’s a mixture of the two. The protagonists Tomos and Wayne aspire to very different courses for their lives, although deep down their motivations are quite similar. They’re both altruists. They both want to Do the Right Thing. But they express it, because of their disparate upbringings, in very different ways.

In the end though, they do achieve a coming together, although in an astonishingly unusual and highly emotionally-charged way. Which I couldn’t possibly divulge, of course!


The One of Us is available from Amazon UK, Amazon US and other Amazons worldwide.






About wordsfromjohn

Once a printer, graphic designer, house renovator and landscape gardener, I'm now retired and a writer of books with a passion.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Nature or nurture?

  1. Pingback: The One of Us by John Needham | Book Reviews by Susan Keefe

  2. John, I am going to enjoy reading this book of yours.

  3. wordsfromjohn says:

    Thank you Marilyn. I do hope so.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s